Method
All-energy self-reliance = island renewable electricity actually used, plus off-grid solar and fuels made on-island, divided by all energy used on the island: grid electricity, road gasoline and diesel, marine fuel, interisland jet fuel, propane and off-road diesel. Energy-content basis, as in the ESR framework. Transpacific flights and shipping are out of scope.
Grid dispatch is annual, with a simple day/night split: geothermal, hydro and wind serve load around the clock; solar serves the daytime half of what’s left; batteries (one cycle a day, 88% round trip) move surplus solar into the night; biofuel and then oil plants fill the rest. Surplus solar is curtailed unless e-fuels are switched on (50% conversion). This is a planning sketch, not a reliability study. Backup floor: each grid tops out at 99% renewable. We assume fuel-fired backup plants still supply at least 1% of each year’s electricity (storms, outages, maintenance, long windless or cloudy spells), and that every island keeps some backup for caution and diversity.
2025 starting point matches HECO’s 2025 RPS filing: 1,381 GWh generated, 57.3% renewable.
Key assumptions (low confidence flagged)
- Base demand +0.5%/yr before electrification.
- Road fuel: 80.4M gal gasoline + 12.2M gal highway diesel (DoTax 2024). EVs use 7.3 kWh per gallon of gasoline replaced and 12 kWh per gallon of diesel. 3.6% of cars electric at the end of 2025 (DBEDT: 42,919 of 1,082,932 passenger vehicles by Sept 2026). Fleet turnover, using the same method as the Hawaii EV Association site calculator: about 50,000 new vehicles join each year and stay ~22 years; today’s EVs leave the road at ~6% a year; the EV share of new sales (13.8% in 2025, HADA) drives the fleet. Even 100% EV sales from 2027 leaves 10% of cars on gas until about 2046. Trucks and buses are assumed to lag cars by five years. “Current plans” holds EV sales at today’s ~14%; the ESR pathway’s EV sales follow the “Steady” S-curve (about 26% of new cars in 2030, 63% in 2035, 91% in 2040), with no early retirement. Island-made fuels go to boats and planes; a switch extends them to the remaining gas and diesel vehicles.
- Interisland jet fuel 708 GWh-eq and marine 108 GWh-eq in 2025, from the ESR workbook’s statewide figures and Big Island shares (low).
- Propane ~8M gal (20% of ~40M gal statewide) and off-road diesel ~9M gal outside power plants (low).
- Off-grid homes ≈ 17.5 GWh/yr of solar, growing 3%/yr. There is no official count (low).
- PGV returns to 2024 output in 2026 and reaches 46 MW at 90% capacity factor in 2027 (timing).
- Hāmākua firm plant (2029) burns today’s amount of biofuel unless you add more. The IGP’s 30 MW of firm capacity adds reliability, not renewable energy, unless it burns biofuel.
- IGP RFP energy (435 GWh/yr) is modeled as solar + storage ramping in 2032–33, with 460 MWh of batteries. Part of it is meant to replace expiring contracts; to test that, tick “Existing wind farms shut down”.
- New rooftop solar comes with about 1 MWh of usable home battery per MW (low). Capacity factors: rooftop 20%, utility solar 24–25%, wind 38%, geothermal 90%.
- Electrifying industry and boats uses 0.4 units of electricity per unit of fuel replaced; electric aircraft the same.